Tuesday, July 31, 2007
Best African Players & A Comment About Censorship
A few days ago I posted about the greatest African player ever. A post like this gets noticed and many people commented with their opinion.
I also managed to get readers from the Big Soccer forum and Xtratime.com community.
Here, I share some of the best comments.
Reader Chxta said: 'As with most things African, this is a topic that would be quite controversial, for example a lot of the titles won by Egyptian clubs have always been hotly debated.
For me it is a straight fight between Milla, Hassan and Kanu.
Milla shone on the world stage, but never got to the pinnacle of club football.
Kanu has shone on the world stage, but arguably in youth competitions (Olympics for example), however truth be told is that he is, the most decorated player in the English Premiership at the moment, and the most decorated African player ever. However, he hasn't even scored a Nations Cup goal much less win the tournament.
I'd probably give it to Hassan on the strength of the impact he had on his country's game.'
BigSoccer poster Cazlon said: 'Unfortunately there is little point in a ranking like this.
Who outside of their respective country still knows about Abdul Razak, Thomas N'Kono, or even the legendary Kalusha Bwalya ?
European/American tabloids don't, certainly not if you limit the selection to the last decade.
Fair enough.
Xtratime reader Andy Christ said: 'It's between Weah and Eto'o and the Cameroonian will probably edge it after another 3-4 good seasons. Drogba might also come close to Weah's legend if he stays in the form he showed last season. Kanu and Okocha have never been world class and Milla never did enough in Europe. Hassan is somebody who is an unknown factor outside Africa but I doubt if that many Africans outside Egypt seriously rate him above Weah or Eto'o.
He may be right. Only time can tell.
The issue isn't settled and only time will tell who really is the greatest African player ever. Kanu? Milla? Eto'o in a few years? Or someone unknown to the masses, as Cazlon pointed out? Let the debate continue.
***************************************************
A few days ago, we posted a story about censorship and FIFA's attempts to discourage use of their brand. We noted the case of Anton Vosloo, who ran the wildly successful www.2010-soccer-worldcup.com. FIFA ordered it shut and the site was closed within days.
This comment comes in from Anton Vosloo himself: 'They said the actual domain name was the problem and not so much the content. There are already much more than 7 sites out there.I think it was more the group of us that had a high page rank on google. My site was a free directory for travel related sites in Southern Afica.
I think it's sad that FIFA has come to this, but maybe they're right? Maybe they do need to protect their assets? What do you think?
Read the article and the posted link in the article to learn more about this story.
******************************************
Kudos to the Iraqi soccer team on their Asian Cup victory. Once again, football uplifts and transforms a nation. The power of a ball. It's incredible ...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment